Lost your password? Please enter your email address. You will receive a link and will create a new password via email.
Please briefly explain why you feel this question should be reported.
Please briefly explain why you feel this answer should be reported.
Please briefly explain why you feel this user should be reported.
When a cop is killed during her last con, the Chinese-Australian suspect finds herself hiding out in a small conservative town in NSW where she takes the persona of a Chinese Medicine healer but finds herself healing the town and herself.
Location is somewhat irrelevant. Her being half Chinese is probably not. Would it make any difference if this story took place in the USA or UK? Currently she doesn't really have a goal. I agree with David, it's hard to picture when it's not clear what she actually wants. Why does she need healing?Read more
Location is somewhat irrelevant. Her being half Chinese is probably not. Would it make any difference if this story took place in the USA or UK?
Currently she doesn’t really have a goal. I agree with David, it’s hard to picture when it’s not clear what she actually wants. Why does she need healing? Why does the town need healing?
It reminds me quite heavily of “To Wong Foo, Thanks for Everything, Julie Newmar” although that film is a comedy (which I can’t imagine yours wouldn’t be to be honest… someone posing as a Chinese medicine healer…). In that film, three drag queens are on a road trip to Hollywood and along the way a cop tries to rape one of them, resulting in them knocking him unconscious (although they believe they killed him). Their car breaks down a little further down the road and they find themselves in a small conservative town and they have no choice but to wait in the town for car parts to arrive. Whilst they are there, they all learn something about themselves and they change the town too. Simple.
Your idea is similar, and there’s nothing wrong with that, but with To Wong Foo, it’s probably the car breaking down that’s the inciting incident. Their goal is to get to Hollywood, when their car breaks down their goal is to get their car fixed so they can get to Hollywood. ?The antagonistic forces are the police, certain members of the town, time (as it delays the car part) – all of these things potentially stop them going to Hollywood. Interestingly though, the drag queen’s sub-plots form a much bigger part of the whole film than the A-story.
A very similar approach could be taken for your idea. The protagonist needs to have an over-arching goal and that needs to relate more heavily to the inciting incident. Everything that happens in this town are your sub-plots and whilst they can be suggested in the logline, we actually need your whole A-story to make a good logline.
Hope this helps.
See lessA lyncanthropic warrior reluctantly teams with a human princess after a mysterious knight, who slaughtered the warrior’s village years ago, returns and begins attacking humans.
Whilst the formula suggested on logline is merely a guideline, I do feel like this version would benefit from it. The reason why this formula is so useful is because, chronologically, it follows the story. Starts with the inciting incident (which in your new version is at the end) and then leads intRead more
Whilst the formula suggested on logline is merely a guideline, I do feel like this version would benefit from it. The reason why this formula is so useful is because, chronologically, it follows the story. Starts with the inciting incident (which in your new version is at the end) and then leads into the journey through Act II.
The protagonist doing something reluctantly… to me this is problematic. Whilst he’s taking action, his reluctance could make the audience wonder why they should care if he doesn’t really want to be there. Obviously, you haven’t stated why he’s reluctant BUT this ambiguity is problematic too.
I’m guessing their goal is to stop the warrior but you haven’t actually stated that. All we have so far is Act I with the break into Act II being where the warrior teams up with the princess. What happens next? What must they do?
Why does he need to team up with the princess? Part of me thinks it might be worth leaving this out of the logline and focussing on the hero’s story. With her introduction, it leaves me with a lot more questions that the word count simply won’t allow for.
Does the story change at all if he’s not a werewolf? I like the idea, I just want to make sure there’s a reason for it.
When the knight who slaughtered his village years ago returns to wreak havoc again, an impulsive young werewolf must XXXXXXXXX
Hope this helps.
See lessAfter losing her arm in a car accident, a prodigious but reckless chef reconciles with her ill father, who encourages her to seek redemption and forgiveness.
Act I should be she is already a highly skilled chef, she's a hard ass, and isn't well liked. Much quicker and you don't have to worry about cramming her rise to where she is in 30mins. Chances are, before she was a great chef, she wasn't quite as "hard-ass" and was more liked by those around her anRead more
Act I should be she is already a highly skilled chef, she’s a hard ass, and isn’t well liked. Much quicker and you don’t have to worry about cramming her rise to where she is in 30mins. Chances are, before she was a great chef, she wasn’t quite as “hard-ass” and was more liked by those around her and it’s the nature of her desire to succeed that she pushed all those things aside to get to where she is. If the audience sees what she was like before she became the great chef, there’s a chance that where she ends up at the end will have less of an impact because the audience will have seen that she can be a better person already. Does that make any sense at all?
I think she should be attending meetings in act II as this is where you’re going to meet the additional characters who provide the different perspectives on her point of view. Act II is all about her fighting between who she was and who she is and there needs to be people who represent both sides of this in her life – past and future – Father and fellow disabled person. As I mentioned before, through one of these characters (the B-Story) she has a turning point that pushes the story into Act III.