Categories: Public
Flash of Light
Good points raised by DPG and Richiev.
The character flaw in many fantasy movies is normally a cliche and waters down the impact of the journey. I think that both DPG and Richiev's suggestions put together are the better option only after she learns her lesson and completes her inner journey is she able to save her brother.
Karel Segeres mentioned the order of the inner and outer goal achievements needing to be that only after the MC achieves the inner goal and completes their arc are they allowed to achieve the outer goal as a reward.
Basically what this means is that achieving the outer journey's goal is a feat and raises its significants, significantly.
Impulsiveness is always a handy character trait to create new problems, but,as Richiev observed, the story seems to have a visual motif of light and darkness. How would impulsiveness fit into that motif? Or do you have another motif in mind?
Impulsiveness is always a handy character trait to create new problems, but,as Richiev observed, the story seems to have a visual motif of light and darkness. How would impulsiveness fit into that motif? Or do you have another motif in mind?
Maybe even more than just 'afraid of the dark' but absolutely terrified of it.
At night she lights her whole house with candles so there is no darkness anywhere in the house and since she was a child she has been told stories about the 'dark realm'; she was told if she was a bad girl monsters from the dark realm would get her.
(It would help if there was some traumatic experience that happened to her when she was just a child, maybe her parents were killed by a creature from the dark real, they enter our world when the shadows are dark enough)
I'm glad we're discussing character flaws. Working out the flaw for the candle maker has been a bit of a challenge for me. My initial idea was that she is impulsive, always rushing into things without thinking them through. Over the course of the story, she would have to be less reckless with her decisions, especially since lives are now on the line. But I like Richiev's idea of a fear of the dark, too.
Richiev,
I like your take, too.
In that scenario, the last thing she would ever want to do must also be the last thing she (finally) MUST do after all other options have been exhausted. Consequently, that ultimate confrontation with darkness would happen around the end of Act 2 -- it would not occur early on or anywhere in the 1st half of Act 2.
And the physical darkness could imply a corresponding subjective internal "heart of darkness" in herself that she must also confront. (Say, akin to Luke Skywalker confronting his Darth Vader shadow-self in "Return of the Jedi".)
The premise has interesting choices.
Richiev,
I like your take, too.
In that scenario, the last thing she would ever want to do must also be the last thing she (finally) MUST do after all other options have been exhausted. Consequently, that ultimate confrontation with darkness would happen around the end of Act 2 -- it would not occur early on or anywhere in the 1st half of Act 2.
And the physical darkness could imply a corresponding subjective internal "heart of darkness" in herself that she must also confront. (Say, akin to Luke Skywalker confronting his Darth Vader shadow-self in "Return of the Jedi".)
The premise has interesting choices.
Well to me her obvious character flow would be 'she's afraid of the dark' which is why she became a candle maker. Now she must do the last thing she would ever want to do. Enter the dark realm.
But that's just my take, not sure where the OP was heading with this.
Yeah, I got the metaphor. And she can still be a candle maker as her day job, as her cover, while she is abusing her powers.
What does "light the way" mean translated into a plot? Her objective goal is to rescue her brother. It seems to me she has to discover how to "light the way" for herself -- subjective need -- before she can do it for anyone else. If her brother is trapped in physical darkness, she's trapped in spiritual darkness.
Or framing if from another perspective: if she's already got the "right stuff", she just needs to use it, then what's her character flaw? What is there for the audience to worry about? That she is doomed because her powers are no match, never will be, for the sorcerer? Not likely if the story has a happy ending.
So, again, what is there for an audience to worry about? What if she has an "Achilles heel" (character flaw) which, when all else fails the sorcerer -- her powers prove equal to his -- threatens to be the means for him to prevail against her? And not just prevail but destroy her?
I see the story in the mythical mold of the Hero's journey, a call to adventure (linked to an objective goal) which implicitly entails a challenge to change, to grow (linked to a subjective need).
fwiw.
Yeah, I got the metaphor. And she can still be a candle maker as her day job, as her cover, while she is abusing her powers.
What does "light the way" mean translated into a plot? Her objective goal is to rescue her brother. It seems to me she has to discover how to "light the way" for herself -- subjective need -- before she can do it for anyone else. If her brother is trapped in physical darkness, she's trapped in spiritual darkness.
Or framing if from another perspective: if she's already got the "right stuff", she just needs to use it, then what's her character flaw? What is there for the audience to worry about? That she is doomed because her powers are no match, never will be, for the sorcerer? Not likely if the story has a happy ending.
So, again, what is there for an audience to worry about? What if she has an "Achilles heel" (character flaw) which, when all else fails the sorcerer -- her powers prove equal to his -- threatens to be the means for him to prevail against her? And not just prevail but destroy her?
I see the story in the mythical mold of the Hero's journey, a call to adventure (linked to an objective goal) which implicitly entails a challenge to change, to grow (linked to a subjective need).
fwiw.
DPG, I believe 'candle maker' is supposed to go with the 'dark realm'.
The world she enters is dark but because she's a candle maker she can light the way and search for her brother.
To me that sounds as if it's the 'hook' of the story.
Now if her magical power had to do with 'creating light' and the evil sorcerers plan was to plunge her world into eternal darkness, that would be interesting.
When an evil sorcerer kidnaps her brother, a young gypsy who has used her psychic powers to exploit others must learn how to use them to defeat the sorcerer.
It seems to me that the premise would benefit from a stronger character arc. That is, she hasn't hidden or repressed her magical powers; rather, she has squandered them, used them for selfish, foolish, negative purposes.
Framed in that way, the aspect of the story that hooks my interest is not that she must rescue her brother -- rescue scenarios are a dime a dozen -- but that in order to rescue him she must first transform herself. She must learn how to transform all her negative energy into positive energy, to retool her talents for good instead of evil.
And, come to find out, the right way to use her talents is also the hardest way.
fwiw.
When an evil sorcerer kidnaps her brother, a young gypsy who has used her psychic powers to exploit others must learn how to use them to defeat the sorcerer.
It seems to me that the premise would benefit from a stronger character arc. That is, she hasn't hidden or repressed her magical powers; rather, she has squandered them, used them for selfish, foolish, negative purposes.
Framed in that way, the aspect of the story that hooks my interest is not that she must rescue her brother -- rescue scenarios are a dime a dozen -- but that in order to rescue him she must first transform herself. She must learn how to transform all her negative energy into positive energy, to retool her talents for good instead of evil.
And, come to find out, the right way to use her talents is also the hardest way.
fwiw.
Thank you so much for all your help. I have a much better understanding of my logline now. :)
As Richiev said inciting incident first is always better.
