Told that he’ll never be a leading man, an overlooked midlife Broadway actor murders and devours his peers who embody the love and success he craves, but every bite only makes him hungrier as he finally steps into the spotlight.

Categories:

3 reviews

Strengths Well-defined POV Active protagonist Filmable incident Causality and coherence Action, not decision Concision No hedging

Needs work Clear, difficult goal Stakes and urgency Specificity

I love the Event. Reminds me of the Tootsie inciting incident. But "murders and devours his peers" feels repetitive and unfocused. How can we visualise/anticipate the ending to this? You can fix this by adding an MPR pivot (look up on this site what I mean).

Former member

Thanks! Can you suggest alternative to replace "murders and devours"? I tried to use "cannibalizes" or just "devours/consumes" but many are confused as metaphor. Can you also briefly explain MPR pivot?

Former member

Also, i find one problem is "peers" is critiqued as vague. But let's say his victims are a mix of people he cares like housemate, mentee or partner AND people he despises like his rival/bully or his agent. What word is suitable to replace so?

Karel Segers · Maestro · 3,010 pts

Hey Roland - When you have an open-ended goal at the end of the first act, often the Mid-Point Reversal refocuses that. Simplest example is Jaws: Until the MPR, the goal is 'protecting the people of Amity' or 'closing the beaches', neither which has a clear visible end point. That changes halfway, when the new goal is to catch the shark, and eliminate the threat. Audiences can visualise this and it gives the film new momentum.

I think "...every bite only makes him hungrier..." works because of the irony, that the hunger for fame and fortune is never sated; it becomes all consuming, figuratively and literally. "Enough" is never enough.

Suggestion: Have you thought of casting the story w/ a female protagonist?

It's a sad fact that the prospects of getting great roles significantly declines in middle aged for female actors. Not so much for male actors; in fact, it can be a turning point when their careers skyrocket. So when a female actor is told she'll never be a star, it's a harder and more certain death sentence on her career aspirations than it is for a man. FWIW.

Former member

Great suggestion! But my protag is actually a gay man. But I also usually write a lot of stories which are centered around women.

dogger · Oracle · 88,930 pts

Then consider making the protagonist bisexual in terms of both her sexual preferences and her "dietary" preferences.

Former member

I like the "bi" pun but I'm good keeping the gay man protag since I'm almost done writing the draft.

dogger · Oracle · 88,930 pts

Understood.
Best wishes.

Strengths Well-defined POV Active protagonist Filmable incident Stakes and urgency Causality and coherence Action, not decision Concision No hedging

Needs work Clear, difficult goal Specificity

The specificity is the weak point: 'his peers' and 'the love and success he craves' are abstract placeholders rather than concrete story beats, and 'steps into the spotlight' is a stock showbiz-trope ending rather than a specific image. The 'every bite only makes him hungrier' line also undercuts a clear final goal and suggests no real change by the end, just an escalating cycle. Ground the premise with a specific role, show, or rival he's consuming pieces of, and clarify what winning or losing actually looks like.

More in Horror

See all →

Browse all loglines →